2721 Erie Ave.

Cincinnati, Ohio

513 533 8081


Historic Church Converted into a Luxury Home!

Extraordinary historic property in Cincinnati!
1835 Baymiller St  Cincinnati, OH 45214
5 Bedrooms | 5 Full, 1 Half Bathrooms | 6 Car Parking

Welcome to the exquisite, award winning, historic church turned single-family home, a gem nestled in the up and coming West End of Cincinnati within The Dayton Street Historic District. This remarkable property seamlessly combines timeless architectural beauty with modern amenities, offering an extraordinary opportunity for a discerning buyer seeking endless income potential through rental or just a unique once in a lifetime home. Located walking distance to the new MLS Stadium, Findlay Market and other downtown areas.

Steeped in history and recognized for its exceptional adaptive reuse, this home boasts a captivating exterior featuring ornate stonework and magnificent original stained glass windows. The stunning craftsmanship and attention to detail evident in every corner make it a true architectural masterpiece. It comes as no surprise that it received an esteemed award from the Cincinnati Preservation Association.

Upon entering this remarkable residence, you are immediately greeted by a grand foyer that exudes elegance and charm with two beautiful staircases that lead to the grand space. The soaring 27’ ceilings, adorned with intricately designed plaster work, create an awe-inspiring atmosphere that is both inviting and breathtaking. Sunlight filters through the resplendent yellow stained glass windows, casting vibrant hues and adding an ethereal touch to the living space.

The home spans across three levels, offering ample space for comfortable living and entertaining. With five large bedrooms, each accompanied by its own full bath, privacy and tranquility are ensured for every resident or guest.

The gourmet kitchen is a chef’s dream, equipped with top-of-the-line appliances, custom cabinetry from Brush Factory and a center island that serves as a focal point for culinary creativity surrounded by beautiful Rookwood tile.

The property’s modern upgrades, including new plumbing, new electric, and four independent HVAC systems, guarantee optimal comfort and convenience. The careful integration of contemporary amenities has been seamlessly executed, ensuring a harmonious blend of old-world charm and modern living.

Beyond the main living spaces, this extraordinary home offers limitless income potential. The expansive floor plan provides versatile opportunities for customization, allowing for the creation of additional living areas, home offices, artist studios, or even a boutique bed and breakfast. The property’s unique history and architectural allure make it an ideal venue for events, weddings, or other special occasions.

Outside, a meticulously maintained yard surrounds the residence, providing a private oasis in the heart of the city with a large lot for off-Street parking potential.

Located in a coveted neighborhood, this historic church-turned-home offers convenience, culture, and charm.

Don’t miss your chance to own a piece of Cincinnati’s rich history while unlocking the boundless potential this unique property offers. Whether you choose to make it your own private haven or embark on a lucrative entrepreneurial venture, this home stands as a testament to timeless beauty and remarkable opportunity.

Three spaces currently renting through Airbnb, with one of the units currently homeowner occupied with projected yearly income up to $140k. Showings start 7/7. 



Schedule Showing